What is a Cookie Drop?

 Our signature bakery-style chocolate chip cookies are baked with premium chocolate, rich brown sugar, and a touch of flaky sea salt. Crisp on the edges and irresistibly soft in the center, each cookie is loaded with melted chocolate in every bite. A timeless favorite, made from our family recipe and baked fresh for every cookie drop. 

Golden on the outside, irresistibly soft on the inside. This classic Snickerdoodle is coated in cinnamon sugar and baked to a perfectly chewy center, creating a cookie that's simple, nostalgic, and impossible to resist. 

A soft-baked matcha cookie made with premium matcha and generously packed with creamy white chocolate chips. Earthy, buttery, and perfectly sweet, with a delicate matcha flavor that pairs beautifully with the rich sweetness of white chocolate.

Baked fresh in small batches right here on Marco Island, this limited-edition flavor is a little unexpected, a little indulgent, and definitely worth trying. 

Seasonal Rotating Flavor- 

Limited Availability!

A rich, fudgy double chocolate cookie loaded with decadent chocolate chips and finished with stretchy marshmallow cream pulled into a spooky spider-web design. Topped with colorful Halloween M&M’s for the perfect festive crunch, this cookie is soft, chewy, chocolatey, and just the right amount of spooky. 🎃

A limited-edition Halloween flavor from Island Cookie Shop, baked fresh in small batches right here on Marco Island.

Can't decide which flavor to try? Our Halloween Cookie Flight lets you sample the entire month's lineup before choosing a favorite!

Each flight includes one full-size gourmet cookie in each of our featured September flavors:
🍪 Chocolate Chip
🍪 Snickerdoodle
🍪 Matcha White Chocolate

🍪 Spider Web Double Chocolate

Perfect for first-time customers, sharing with a friend, or treating yourself to a little taste of everything. Available only during our September 12th Cookie Drop while supplies last.

5 Custom Sugar Cookies

Create sweet summer memories with our coastal-inspired cookie decorating experience. Each kit includes four hand-cut beach-themed sugar cookies, one edible artist palette cookie featuring four coastal watercolor shades, and a food-safe paintbrush. Simply dip the brush in water and paint your cookies just like a masterpiece from the shore.

Perfect for beach days, family activities, gifts, and summer celebrations.

 A little Halloween magic to decorate at home. 🎃

Five handcrafted sugar cookies, ready to decorate with everything you need for a spooky-sweet afternoon at home.

Each kit includes:

• 5 handcrafted Halloween sugar cookies 
• 5 bags of royal icing in Halloween colors 
• Halloween sprinkles 
• Candy eyes 
• Decorating tool 
• Beautiful gift-ready packaging 

No tricks. Just treats. 🕷️

Perfect for Halloween parties, a fun afternoon with the kids, classroom treats, or a cozy night of decorating at home.

Limited quantities